what were 3 major ships that sunk in pearl harbour WI Pearl Harbor was done right -- Part III - FireBoard - Hairstyle magazine, hairstyle for 2008, 2009

	FireBoard	Forum Threaded View Rules Help

Welcome, Guest
Please Login or Register. Lost Password?

FireBoard

General Discussion

Others

what were 3 major ships that sunk in pearl harbour WI Pearl Harbor was done right -- Part III (1 viewing) (1) Guests

Favoured: 0

TOPIC: what were 3 major ships that sunk in pearl harbour WI Pearl Harbor was done right -- Part III

Forum Tools

#19335

Douglas Muir (Visitor)

what were 3 major ships that sunk in pearl harbour WI Pearl Harbor was done right -- Part III
(For those who came late, this is part III of a TL that assumes the Japanese strike on Pearl Harbor was more effective than in OTL

Report to moderator Logged

Logged

The administrator has disabled public write access.

#19336

Douglas Muir (Visitor)

what were 3 major ships that sunk in pearl harbour WI Pearl Harbor was done right -- Part III

However, I have a few qualms. You obviously know more about Japanese strategy, tactics, and society in this period than I do. But reading over this, it is hard not to see the Japanese as, well, bozos. They can't coordinate their attacks, their fail to make critical rendezvous for major battles, they abandon support of a critical invasion to try for a Decisive Final Battle..... The failure to rendezvous is Inoue's goof, and I think it's consistent with his character as seen in OTL. He tended to be either timid or stubborn

Report to moderator Logged

Logged

The administrator has disabled public write access.

#19337

Stephen Lazer (Visitor)

what were 3 major ships that sunk in pearl harbour WI Pearl Harbor was done right -- Part III
(For those who came late, this is part III of a TL that assumes the Japanese strike on Pearl Harbor was more effective than in OTL

Report to moderator Logged

Logged

The administrator has disabled public write access.

Forum List

General Discussion

Others